Pedal Your Way Through Islamorada’s Key Lime Culinary Trail

The Florida Keys’ signature citrus flavor isn’t just for pie—it’s infused into ice cream, cocktails, seafood, and even beer. We invite you to explore it all on The Islands of Islamorada's new Key Lime Culinary Trail, our resort curated self-guided tasting tour featuring some of our concierge team's favorites from the island’s most beloved Key lime-infused treats.

With complimentary bike rentals available for guests, you can cruise along the coast and stop at iconic cafés, seafood hotspots, breweries, and sweet shops, all within a three-mile radius of the resort.

Stops Along the Key Lime Culinary Trail

Midway Cafe

Start your journey at this charming café, located at mile marker 80.5, exactly halfway between Miami and Key West. Their Key Lime Pie Frappe is a must-try, blending the sweet and tangy flavors of the Keys into a refreshing frozen drink. Pair it with a freshly baked pastry or organic coffee for the perfect pre-ride fuel.

Visit website

Lazy Days

Savor an award-winning catch of the day at Lazy Days, one of Islamorada’s top-rated seafood restaurants. The **fresh local fish** is encrusted in Japanese breadcrumbs, sautéed to perfection, and topped with Key Lime Butter—a dish so incredible it was featured on Man’s Greatest Food.

visit website

Keys Chocolate & Ice Cream

For a refreshing twist on a classic dessert, stop by this family-owned sweet shop for a scoop of Key Lime Pie Ice Cream. Their handcrafted recipes have been passed down for generations, ensuring an authentic taste of the Keys in every bite.

visit website

Islamorada Brewery & Distillery

Sip your way through island flavors at the first and only microbrewery and distillery in the Florida Keys. Try the No Wake Zone Coconut Key Lime Blonde Ale or cool off with a frozen Key Lime Cocktail, both available to-go so you can keep the adventure going.

visit website

Lorelie's

An Islamorada institution since 1952, Lorelei’s is the go-to spot for waterfront dining, live music, and legendary sunsets. Order the Key Lime Colada, a tropical frozen treat as iconic as the café’s mermaid sign, which has been repainted by renowned artists over the years.

visit website

Pedal, Taste, and Explore Islamorada

Whether you're indulging in seafood by the water, sipping a Key lime cocktail, or cooling off with citrusy ice cream, The Islands of Islamorada's Key Lime Culinary Trail offers a flavor-filled way to explore Islamorada.

Ready to embark on the ultimate Key lime adventure? Book your stay at The Islands of Islamorada and enjoy complimentary bike rentals to experience the best Key lime flavors the Florida Keys have to offer.